Tithing: Divine Principle or Church Hustle?

“She all ah tell mi about the one Deacon. Who ah drive the big Benz ah where him get money from. That's why nobody nah want give no collection.” — Shaggy, "Church Heathen" 

Sound familiar? From my eyes were at my knees until now, the church community has grappled with many issues, one being that of tithes and offerings. But what exactly are these? 

Understanding Tithes and Offerings 

Tithes and offerings are financial contributions made by believers to support their local church and its ministries. The term "tithe" originates from the Old English word "teogotha," meaning "tenth," reflecting the practice of giving 10% of one's income. Offerings, on the other hand, are additional gifts given beyond the tithe, often designated for specific purposes or needs within the church community.

The Biblical Origins of Tithing 

The concept of tithing predates Mosaic Law, with its earliest mention in the Bible found in Genesis 14:18-20. Here, Abram (later Abraham) encounters Melchizedek, the king of Salem and priest of God Most High. In gratitude for a blessing, Abram gives Melchizedek a tenth of all his possessions. This act signifies recognition of God's provision and sovereignty. 

Later, in Leviticus 27:30, the Israelites are instructed: "A tithe of everything from the land, whether grain from the soil or fruit from the trees, belongs to the Lord; it is holy to the Lord." This establishes tithing as a divine ordinance, reinforcing the principle of dedicating a portion of one's earnings to God. 

Contemporary Challenges and Misuses 

Recently, tithing has come under scrutiny due to instances where church leaders have exploited it for personal gain. The rise of "prosperity gospel" preachers, who promise divine blessings in exchange for financial contributions, has led many to question the true purpose of tithing. 

For example, some self-proclaimed prophets have been known to request monetary "seeds" in exchange for prophetic words or miracles. This practice has been criticized for preying on vulnerable individuals seeking spiritual guidance. As highlighted in discussions about false prophets, such actions are seen as manipulative and contrary to genuine biblical teaching. 

Additionally, certain church leaders have discouraged giving to the poor, emphasizing tithing to the church as the primary avenue for receiving God's blessings. Pastor Keion Henderson, founder of The Lighthouse Church & Ministries in Houston, Texas, faced backlash after a sermon where he suggested that blessings come from tithing to the church rather than giving to the needy. Critics argued that this perspective contradicts biblical teachings on charity and compassion. 

The Impact on Congregations 

Such controversies have led to a growing skepticism among believers regarding the allocation and use of church funds. Stories of leaders living lavish lifestyles—driving luxury cars and residing in opulent homes—while congregants struggle financially have fueled distrust. This disparity often discourages members from contributing, fearing their hard-earned money is funding extravagance rather than ministry work. 

Moreover, some congregants feel pressured to give beyond their means, with leaders emphasizing sacrificial giving as a demonstration of faith. This can lead to financial strain and resentment, especially when transparency about fund usage is lacking. 

The Essence of Tithing

Despite these challenges, the fundamental question remains: Should believers continue to tithe? If one holds the belief that "the earth is the Lord's, and everything in it" (Psalm 24:1), then tithing becomes an act of acknowledging God's sovereignty over all possessions. Jesus also taught, "Give back to Caesar what is Caesar's, and to God what is God's" (Matthew 22:21), highlighting the importance of fulfilling both civic and divine obligations. 

Furthermore, the principle of generosity is echoed in Luke 6:38: "Give, and it will be given to you. A good measure, pressed down, shaken together and running over, will be poured into your lap." This underscores the blessings associated with a giving heart. 

Balancing Accountability and Faith 

Churches need to maintain transparency and accountability in financial matters. Congregants have a right to know how their contributions are utilized, ensuring funds support genuine ministry efforts and community needs. This sentiment was echoed recently when a video resurfaced of renowned gospel singer Marvin Sapp ordering ushers, rather sternly, to “close the doors,” as he proceeded to tell congregants, in the sanctuary and watching online, to give $20 each in an effort to raise USD40,000.

However, it's equally important for believers to examine their own hearts and motivations. Are we withholding tithes due to distrust, or are we seeking excuses to avoid giving? While there have been instances of misuse, many ministries operate with integrity, using funds to further the Gospel and serve communities. 

A Call to Discernment and Generosity 

Tithing, at its core, is a personal covenant between the believer and God. It reflects trust, obedience, and recognition of God's provision. While it's crucial to be vigilant against exploitation and to demand accountability from church leaders, we must also guard against allowing cynicism to hinder our generosity.

As believers, we're called to support the work of the ministry, assist those in need and steward our resources wisely. By doing so, we honour God and ensure that our contributions have a meaningful impact. 

In the end, the act of giving isn't just about the transaction; it's about the transformation it brings—both in the lives of others and within our own hearts.

Akeelia Thompson

Contributor

Akeelia Thompson, affectionately known as “Your Favourite Creativepreneur,” is a writer for noblemedianetwork.com. She is a visionary leader, faith-driven strategist and passionate storyteller committed to helping individuals unlock their God-ordained purpose. As the Founder and Creative Director of Souled Into Purpose International (SIP), she guides listeners and community members on the transformative journey of discovering, embracing and living out their unique calling.